Philosophers have been puzzled for quite some time by the fact that intelligent and generally reasonable individuals who are equally well-informed and familiar with the same bodies of evidence still disagree with one another. Legal theorists wonder why this is puzzling for philosophers in the first place as disagreement is the very foundation of their work. This book, placed at the intersection of philosophical epistemology and jurisprudence, deals with the theoretical challenges that disagreements between judges create. The philosophical debate is applied to German and American legal…mehr
Philosophers have been puzzled for quite some time by the fact that intelligent and generally reasonable individuals who are equally well-informed and familiar with the same bodies of evidence still disagree with one another. Legal theorists wonder why this is puzzling for philosophers in the first place as disagreement is the very foundation of their work. This book, placed at the intersection of philosophical epistemology and jurisprudence, deals with the theoretical challenges that disagreements between judges create. The philosophical debate is applied to German and American legal disputes. How can such disagreements be integrated into the general philosophical debate on »peer disagreement« and into the legal theory of judicial decisionmaking? How should one deal with such disagreements under the existing legal framework but also in terms of legal policy?
Isabell Villanueva studierte Rechtswissenschaften, Philosophie und Kunstgeschichte an der Universität Trier, der Universidad de Sevilla, der Westfälischen Wilhelms-Universität Münster und der Humboldt Universität zu Berlin. Von 2013 bis 2018 promovierte sie als Elsa-Neumann- und Caroline von Humboldt-Stipendiatin bei Prof. Dr. Keil und Prof. Dr. Christoph Möllers zu »Peer Disagreement in Law« mit einem zweieinhalbjährigen Forschungsaufenthalt an der New York University und Columbia University in den USA unter der Betreuung von Paul Boghossian und Joseph Raz. Seit 2019 ist sie als Richterin in Berlin tätig.
Inhaltsangabe
I. IntroductionPeer Disagreement in Law - Deep Disagreements - Chapter Summary - Limitations II. Supreme Court: Hobby LobbyThe Battle for Universal Health Care - The Hobby Lobby Case - The Disagreements Involved in the Hobby Lobby Case - The Disagreements in Detail - Overview of the Sources of Disagreement - Analysis Disagreements - The Contraception Mandate Debate: Deep DisagreementsIII. Bundesverfassungsgericht: IncestIncest and the Criminal Law - The Incest Case - The Disagreements Involved in Incest - Disagreements in Detail - Overview Sources of Disagreement - Analysis Disagreements - The Incest Debate: Deep DisagreementsIV. Disagreeing JusticesPeer Disagreement and Disagreeing Justices - Ideology and Disagreeing Justices - ConclusionV. Dealing with DisagreementLegal Practice - Legal Policy - Legal Disagreement and PhilosophyReferencesIndex
I. IntroductionPeer Disagreement in Law - Deep Disagreements - Chapter Summary - Limitations II. Supreme Court: Hobby LobbyThe Battle for Universal Health Care - The Hobby Lobby Case - The Disagreements Involved in the Hobby Lobby Case - The Disagreements in Detail - Overview of the Sources of Disagreement - Analysis Disagreements - The Contraception Mandate Debate: Deep DisagreementsIII. Bundesverfassungsgericht: IncestIncest and the Criminal Law - The Incest Case - The Disagreements Involved in Incest - Disagreements in Detail - Overview Sources of Disagreement - Analysis Disagreements - The Incest Debate: Deep DisagreementsIV. Disagreeing JusticesPeer Disagreement and Disagreeing Justices - Ideology and Disagreeing Justices - ConclusionV. Dealing with DisagreementLegal Practice - Legal Policy - Legal Disagreement and PhilosophyReferencesIndex
Es gelten unsere Allgemeinen Geschäftsbedingungen: www.buecher.de/agb
Impressum
www.buecher.de ist ein Internetauftritt der buecher.de internetstores GmbH
Geschäftsführung: Monica Sawhney | Roland Kölbl | Günter Hilger
Sitz der Gesellschaft: Batheyer Straße 115 - 117, 58099 Hagen
Postanschrift: Bürgermeister-Wegele-Str. 12, 86167 Augsburg
Amtsgericht Hagen HRB 13257
Steuernummer: 321/5800/1497
USt-IdNr: DE450055826