Antonio Cassese

Five Masters of International Law (eBook, PDF)

Conversations with R-J Dupuy, E Jiménez de Aréchaga, R Jennings, L Henkin and O Schachter

• Format: PDF

Produktbeschreibung

This book consists of interviews with five distinguished international lawyers from the UK, USA, Uruguay and France, conducted by the editor, Antonio Cassese, between 1993 and 1995. Each interview is preceded by a brief 'intellectual portrait' of the interviewee. In his general introduction Cassese stresses that the interviews, all based on the same questionnaire, were intended to bring out not only the main ideas associated with each scholar in the fields of international law and international relations, but also his intellectual and philosophical background, his general outlook and his views of the prospects for the evolution of the international community. In his final essay, Cassese brings together the main threads of the interviews and points to the parallels and divergences appearing from them.

This book offers a unique and important insight into the legal minds and outlook of a select group of prominent scholars of international law and legal institutions during the last years of the twentieth century.

Produktdetails

• Verlag: Bloomsbury UK eBooks
• Seitenzahl: 306
• Erscheinungstermin: 15. März 2011
• Englisch
• ISBN-13: 9781847316387
• Artikelnr.: 53201329

Autorenporträt

Antonio Cassese is an international lawyer who has combined a career as a university professor with membership of important UN bodies, and, latterly, membership of several international tribunals. Most recently (1993-2000) he was a judge and President (1993-1997) of the UN International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia, Chairman of the UN International Commission of Inquiry into Crimes in Darfur (Sudan), Independent Expert appointed by the UN Secretary-General to review the efficiency of the Special Court for Sierra Leone, and, since March 2009, Judge and President of the Special Tribunal for Lebanon.

Inhaltsangabe

Basic Questionnaire
René-Jean Dupuy
Interview with René-Jean Dupuy: June 1993
I. The Formative Years
II. Encounters with Other International Lawyers
III. The Role of the Jurist as Scholar and Practitioner
IV. A Look at the International Community
V. The Jurist and Global Reality
Eduardo Jiménez de Aréchaga
Interview with Eduardo Jiménez de Aréchaga: November 1993
I. The Role of Legal Scholarship at the Start of Judge de Aréchaga's Scholarly Activity
II. Meeting Other International Lawyers
III. Jiménez de Aréchaga's Academic and Political Career
IV. Thoughts About the International Community
V. The Jurist and Global Reality
Sir Robert Jennings
Interview with Sir Robert Jennings: October 1994
I. The Beginning as a Scholar
II. Encounters with Other Scholars
III. The Role of the Jurist as Scholar and Practitioner
IV. A Look at the International Community
V. The Jurist and Global Reality
Louis Henkin
Interview with Louis Henkin: February 1995
I. The Formative Years
II. Encounters with Other International Lawyers
III. The Role of the Jurist as Scholar and Practitioner
IV. A Look at the International Community
V. Some Personal Questions
Oscar Schachter
Interview with Oscar Schachter: February 1995
I. The Beginning as a Scholar
II. The Policy-Science Approach versus the Strictly Legal Approach
III. Encounters with Other International Lawyers
IV. The Theoretical Approach to International Law
V. The Role of the Jurist as Scholar and Practitioner
VI. A Look at the International Community
VII. The Jurist and Global Reality
Final Remarks
By Way of Conclusion
I. On the Limits of my Attempt to Highlight the Main Points of the Interviews
II. Basic Commonalities
III. The European Kernel in the Education of the Interviewees
IV. Legal Positivism
V. Scholar versus Practitioner
VI. Political Involvement
VII. The Evils of the Current International Community
VIII. The Outlook for the World Community
IX. Personal Matters
X. Final Observations

Rezensionen

Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung | Besprechung von 12.08.2011

Recht, theoriefern

Mit fünf Meistern des internationalen Rechts hat der Völkerrechtler und ehemalige Präsident des Haager Jugoslawien-Tribunals Antonio Cassese, selbst ein eminenter Vertreter des Faches, zwischen 1993 und 1995 lange Gespräche geführt. Es ist ein Glücksfall, dass der heutige Präsident des Sondertribunals für den Libanon, ein vielbeschäftigter Richter und Wissenschaftler, die Protokolle seiner sorgfältig konzipierten Interviews nun endlich veröffentlicht hat, mit einem erhellenden Vorwort und klugen Schlussbemerkungen. René-Jean Dupuy, Sir Robert Jennings, Eduardo Jiménez de Aréchaga, Louis Henkin und Oscar Schachter haben Cassese ausführlich und in großer Offenheit Auskunft über ihr Leben und Werk, ihre professionellen Prägungen und persönlichen Leidenschaften gegeben. Immer wieder geht es auch um den Einfluss der vorangegangenen Generation eines Kelsen, Scelle und Lauterpacht auf die fünf Akteure, die nach 1945 ihre Laufbahn begannen und sämtlich auch erfahrene Praktiker waren, insbesondere im Feld der Menschenrechte und des humanitären Völkerrechts. "Ich lernte zu schätzen, wie sich das Recht durch Antworten auf konkrete Fragen weiterentwickelt", resümiert Oscar Schachter, der nach mehr als dreißig Jahren als Rechtsberater in den Diensten der Vereinten Nationen bis weit ins neunte Lebensjahrzehnt einen Lehrstuhl an der Columbia Law School innehatte. Es ist vielleicht kein Zufall, dass die Protagonisten des Bandes bei allen Unterschieden doch eine Art pragmatischer Theorieferne verbindet, eine Absage an intellektuelle Formationen und akademische Schulen - und die Skepsis gegenüber jener nachfolgenden Generation kritischer Völkerrechtler, deren herausragende Vertreter in den vergangenen zwanzig Jahren selbst zu einflussreichen Schulhäuptern geworden sind. (Antonio Cassese: "Five Masters of International Law". Hart Publishing, Oxford and Portland, Oregon, 2011. 286 S., br., 36,99 [Euro].)

ake.

Alle Rechte vorbehalten. © F.A.Z. GmbH, Frankfurt am Main

This book...filled me with admiration. It is so typical of certain features of Nino's character, especially his intellectual curiosity and his modesty. Nino, himself a great master of international law, felt the need to interview five masters of international law. It is also highly significant that he emphasizes and praises the human qualities of the interviewees, which were also his own, such as simplicity, affability, gentleness, urbanity, esprit de finesse and witty irony.

Each interview makes for lively and interesting reading: one grasps the rich and different personalities of the interviewees...In spite and beyond their differences, they present important common features. All of them embraced legal positivism, though to varying degrees.
Peter Leuprecht Journal of International Criminal Justice Volume 10